The immediate impact of this trade sees Simon Nemec moving to a new organization where he is expected to receive an elevated role and more ice time with the Calgary Flames. This could provide the young defenseman with the opportunity to develop into the top-pairing player many projected him to be when he was drafted. For the New Jersey Devils, the trade frees up a roster spot and provides considerable future draft capital, offering significant flexibility as the team looks to retool or rebuild its roster. Fans in New Jersey will likely scrutinize how management utilizes these picks in the coming years, while Flames supporters will be keen to see Nemec integrate into their lineup and demonstrate his potential. Etienne Morin, as a prospect, will continue his development path, likely in junior hockey or the AHL, with an eye towards making the Devils' NHL roster in a few seasons.
Image: courtesy of Sportsnaut
Devils Trade Simon Nemec to Flames for Three High Draft Picks, Signaling New Jersey's Future-First Strategy
The New Jersey Devils yesterday traded defenseman Simon Nemec, a former second overall draft pick, and forward Maxim Tsyplakov to the Calgary Flames. In return, the Devils acquired prospect defenseman Etienne Morin, a 2026 second-round pick, a 2027 first-round pick, and a 2028 first-round pick. This move clearly signals a strategic shift for the Devils, prioritizing future asset accumulation and long-term roster construction, while the Flames are making a significant bet on Nemec's high-end potential to bolster their defensive corps immediately.
Outlook
Background
The trade, confirmed on June 23, 2026, involves several key pieces. For the Calgary Flames, the centerpiece is defenseman Simon Nemec, who was the second overall pick in the 2022 NHL Entry Draft. Nemec, still only 22 years old, has shown flashes of brilliance but, as The Athletic notes, has "mostly struggled in the NHL so far" to consistently live up to his high draft pedigree. He brings offensive upside and strong skating but has faced challenges in defensive consistency. Joining Nemec in Calgary is forward Maxim Tsyplakov, whose role and impact are expected to be more depth-oriented.
The New Jersey Devils, in exchange, received a substantial package of future assets. This includes prospect defenseman Etienne Morin, a promising player in his own right, who offers another defensive piece for the Devils' pipeline. More critically, the Devils acquired three high draft selections: a 2026 second-round pick (originally from the New York Rangers), a 2027 first-round pick (originally from the Vegas Golden Knights), and an additional 2028 first-round pick. The acquisition of two future first-round picks, particularly from other teams, provides the Devils with potentially high-value selections, depending on the performance of the Rangers and Golden Knights in those respective seasons. This influx of draft capital suggests a clear long-term vision for the Devils' management.
See also
Precedents
Trading a high draft pick with NHL experience for future draft picks and prospects is a well-worn path in the NHL, often signaling a team's pivot towards a rebuild or significant retooling. Historically, such moves carry inherent risks and rewards for both sides. Teams acquiring young, high-potential players like Nemec are often looking to capitalize on a change of scenery or an expanded role, hoping to unlock the player's full capabilities. Think of past trades involving young defensemen who struggled initially but flourished elsewhere, like Dougie Hamilton (though he moved for established players, the principle of a change of environment applies).
Conversely, teams like the Devils, shedding a recent high draft pick, are making a calculated bet on the future. The value of draft picks is notoriously difficult to predict. A first-round pick, while highly coveted, is far from a guaranteed NHL star. Studies on NHL draft success rates show that even top-10 picks have a significant chance of not becoming an elite player, and the further down the draft you go, the higher the risk. However, accumulating multiple first-round picks significantly increases a team's chances of landing future cornerstone players. The 2018 Erik Karlsson trade, for example, saw the Senators acquire multiple picks and prospects, allowing them to rebuild, albeit over a longer timeline. These types of transactions are often judged years down the line, once the acquired picks have been used and the players developed.
This trade represents a fundamental divergence in philosophy between the New Jersey Devils and the Calgary Flames, with significant implications for both franchises, their rosters, and their fan bases. For the Devils, moving Simon Nemec, a player they invested the second overall pick in just four years prior, is a stark admission that their current trajectory requires a deeper reset or a more patient approach to team building. It suggests a focus on capital allocation towards future talent rather than trying to force immediate returns from a player who has not yet met expectations. By acquiring three high draft picks and a promising defensive prospect in Etienne Morin, the Devils gain immense flexibility. These picks can be used to select elite talent in future drafts, or they can be packaged as currency to acquire established players if the team identifies a specific need down the line. This move provides the general manager with significant leverage and options, albeit at the cost of a player who still holds considerable raw potential.
For the Calgary Flames, this is a clear "gamble," as The Athletic puts it, but one rooted in the immediate need for a top-tier defenseman. Nemec, despite his struggles, possesses the raw tools—skating, offensive instincts, and hockey IQ—to become a difference-maker. Calgary is betting that a new environment, potentially a larger role, and different coaching can unlock that potential. If Nemec thrives in Calgary, the Flames will have acquired a foundational piece for their blue line for years to come. If he continues to struggle, the cost of three high draft picks will be a heavy price to pay, potentially setting back their own competitive window. This trade puts immense pressure on the Flames' development staff and coaching to maximize Nemec's talent, and on Nemec himself to seize this fresh start. It is a high-stakes move for a franchise looking to solidify its defensive core and push for contention.
Scenarios
AnalysisThe consequences of this trade could unfold in several distinct ways, shaping the fortunes of both the New Jersey Devils and the Calgary Flames for the next half-decade.
One possible outcome is that Simon Nemec flourishes in Calgary. Given a prominent role and a fresh start, he may develop into the top-pairing defenseman his draft position suggested, anchoring the Flames' blue line for years. This would validate Calgary's aggressive move, making the investment in draft picks appear shrewd.
Conversely, Nemec could continue to struggle with consistency or defensive liabilities in Calgary. If he fails to meet expectations, the Flames would have sacrificed valuable future assets for a player who doesn't pan out, potentially leaving them without both an elite defenseman and the draft capital to acquire one. This would put significant pressure on the team's management and scouting departments.
For the New Jersey Devils, the future hinges on how they utilize the acquired draft picks. One scenario sees them successfully drafting and developing multiple impact players from the 2026, 2027, and 2028 drafts. This could accelerate their retooling process, creating a deeper, more talented roster in the long term and potentially building a sustained contender.
Another outcome for the Devils is that they could use these picks as trade bait. They might package one or more of the first-round selections to acquire an established, high-impact player who fits their current competitive window, rather than waiting for prospects to develop. This would be a more immediate approach to bolstering their roster, but it carries the risk of giving up potential future stars.
Finally, the development of prospect Etienne Morin is another key variable. He could progress steadily through the Devils' system, eventually becoming a reliable NHL defenseman, adding another layer of value to the trade for New Jersey. Alternatively, his development might stall, diminishing the overall return for the Devils.
Timeline
Frequently Asked Questions
Discussion
Be the first to share your thoughts.